It merely means that you can save time in loading and unloading your items, regardless of which side of the car you are standing. I made the same choice recently and based on looking at both of them I think the Thule looks cooler but Yakima has better build quality, crossbar attachment system, and a better locking system. Thule is a Swedish company thats been around since 1942. In this Thule vs. Yakima cargo box review, we examined the features, highlights, and even the downgrades of each listed cargo box. For instance, Yakimas cargo box models have a textured finish. in this thread in this sub-forum in the entire site. One of the main indicators of quality for a cargo box is the overall rigidity of the frame, particularly with the lid. However, we did find some of the glossier models, such as the Yakima GrandTour or the Thule Motion XT XL, to be slightly more prone to showing scuffs and scrapes than the matte or satin-finished models something to consider if you frequently store your cargo carrier off of your vehicle. The only difference is that the previous was easy to hand-tighten while the latter has that click that lets you know youve tightened the box enough. The Yakima HoldUp Evo is pretty similar to The Thule T2 regarding the size and bike capacity. Black Glossy. A good game of Goldilocks will help you. The RocketBox is very easy to use and feels well-made and secure. With its superior durability, easiness of use, and excellent functionality, this would be a perfect cargo box for your next outdoor adventure. Each box was left on for several weeks and driven for hundreds of miles. It is more convenient to use and requires little to no effort. Opening the SkyBox's sturdy lid with ease. The Comparison: Thule Force vs. Yakima Skybox. You will discover that there are some features you can live without. The handy pull-cord. Both Yakima Skybox and Thule Force will leave you confident in trusting your things inside it. I made a 2" riser out of wood, got new, longer U-bolts to attach the box and it just barely clears. However, make sure that you dont store your valuable items in this cargo box, such as a laptop and other gadgets. They were completely ready to mount out of the box. As a thank you for your contribution, you'll get nearly no ads in the Community and Groups sections. What do you like about your box versus the Thule Motion XT or Yakima GrandTour? We weren't the biggest fans of the surface texture and finish on the shorter, stubbier cargo boxes. It weighs only four pounds, which is important because some systems can weigh down a car and negatively affect fuel economy. However, these do show dirt and scrapes a bit more readily. In this review of the Thule vs. Yakima cargo box, you will be able to select the most suitable cargo box for you. And, while you cant buy it to experience it, feel it from other people who did. We won't accept manufacturer's freebies. Also, Thule cargo boxes feature pull chords. As mentioned earlier, Yakima is living by producing a rugged-looking and no-nonsense cargo box. Anyone who owned a Yakima product before knows that this company is known for combining functionality and style into one perfect cargo box. They have factory-installed locks but lack any extra indicators or ergonomic handles. We also like that the clamps cannot be loosened unless the box is opened, aiming to prevent someone from undoing the clamps from the outside and taking off with the entire cargo box and the gear within. We love matte black. The classy Yakima GrandTour has an almost mirror-like finish. How can we improve GearLab? However, we do have one concern about the GrandTour when it comes to durability. Thule Motion XT Rooftop Cargo Box - 16 cu ft - Black Glossy (485 reviews) Code: TH629706 Retail: $1,532.00 Our Price: $899.95 Roof Box Aero Bars Elliptical Bars Factory Bars Round Bars Square Bars Medium Length High Profile Large Capacity Dual Side Access Black Thule more information > Product Page this Question was Asked From Thule Forces mounting had the same system as its predecessor Motion XT. It isn't too much of a hassle to take on and off a car once you get the hang of it, and it can hold skis/snowboards up to 210 cm in length a rarity for budget cargo carriers. By Thule Thule Motion XT L Black Cargo Box. Here are the following top eight Thule and Yakima cargo boxes to consider: [amazon fields=B01N41AAQR value=thumb image_size=medium image_align=center image_title =thule vs yakima cargo box image_alt = Motion XT XL Cargo Box by Thule image_width=250 image_height=250/]. Unfortunately, the glossy finish is more prone to scuffs and scratches. In terms of dimensions, the Yakima HoldUp Evo is very similar, as is the capacity. We are a bit more concerned about water resistance regarding the SportRack Vista XL and SportRack Horizon Alpine. We buy all the products ourselves. From left to right: Yakima SkyBox, Yakima ShowCase, Thule Motion XT, Thule Force, SportRack Vista, Thule Sidekick. Stylishly-designed, the Thule Motion XT XL is worth the investment. Will it stand durable against external factors? The Yakima Carbonite 16 Cargo Box is not an exception. In the market, Thule and Yakima are one of the best manufacturers of cargo boxes. For this review, we looked at the 10 best models and tested them head-to-head to find out which rooftop cargo-carrying solution came out on top. No, not really. Two excellent products are HighRoad and HighSpeed. That way, you dont accidentally drive with an open cargo box. First to consider is the material used. One downside to the smooth interior is the need for a separate tool to tighten or loosen the clamps. However, it can be a bit expensive. Thanks to its strong plastic material, it can protect the items from heavy weather and even moisture. Features 15 cu. This gives a definite boost for versatility and personalization. However, if you are to choose between the two brands, there are differences to pin down. They build cargo boxes with durability in mind, earning the trust of millions of customers. Its solid forefront design is an indication of years of service that this cargo box can offer. The installation of this cargo box is a breeze. Content on piloteers.org is generated by its users. View warranty details Spare parts Popular bundle Thule Motion XT XL roof box black glossy $949.95 Thule MultiLift multilift aluminium $329.95 Thule GoPack Set bag for roof box 4-pack black $279.95 $1,559.85 The low profile of this Thule Hyper XL cargo box makes it very stylish for storage space. The remainder of the boxes, like the RocketBox Pro 14, are all average in terms of security. round, square, aero, elliptical, and most factory crossbarsMaximum crossbar dimensions: 3-1/2 inches wide x 1-11/16 inches tallCrossbar spread: 23-5/8 inches 35-3/8 inches, round, square, aero, elliptical, and most factory crossbarsMaximum crossbar dimensions: 3-1/2 inches x 1-11/16 inchesCrossbar spread: 24 inches 42 inches. It opens on both sides, is quite durable and secure, and looks good on most cars. It also contributes to its stability when attached to the car. TopRide is easy to install, but it doesnt fit as many vehicles and doesnt come with a lifetime warranty like the HighRoad. We looked for fairly rigid lids that aligned the latching mechanisms without issue. They are some of the most resistant to water intrusion in our experience as well, and the different clamps and latches all feel well-designed. You will come to appreciate an aerodynamic cargo box, especially when youre driving at high speeds. Depending on what you need, youll be able to choose the best Thule or Yakima cargo box for you. We buy all the products ourselves. The GoPlus Carrier also features quick clamps and opens on both sides. It has a dual-opening lid so you can access your gear from both sides of the car, and the quick clamps make installation and removal a breeze. For the most part, every box in this review passed the rain and wind tests, which were easy to account for in the Eastern Sierra in springtime, but some had more questionable design features than others. While there are a few cases where one company has a clear advantage (such as the Thule Hullavator for lift-assisted kayak loading) for the most part there is no difference in quality between the accessories of each brand. Thule, with all its fame and reputation in the hauling industry, is certainly one of the most expensive brands. Both brands also offer durability, security, style, and functionality in one box. These products give you extra cargo space so that you can hold all kinds of equipment. Got feedback? I am looking at these low profile boxes specifically for garage clearance issues and aerodynamics to keep on most of the time. You dont need to exert force when opening a box and putting your gears inside. We found the Thule Vector, Yakima GrandTour, Thule Motion XT XL, Thule Force XT XL, Yakima Skybox Carbonite 16, Yakima RocketBox Pro 14, and Thule Pulse all to be the frontrunners in terms of quality. That means, there wont be any chances you lock your keys inside the box or misplace it somewhere. Thule is highly resistant to any kind of weather, whereas Yakima Cargo Box are not as water-resistant. Cracked roof using roof rack w/ cargo box, For Sale: Tesla OEM Roof Racks and Thule Motion XT L Gloss Black roof box, Is Yakima FullSwing bike rack wobble normal. With proper use and maintenance, this cargo box will ensure the safety of your gears at all times. Trying out each thumbwheel and finding the right level of tightness will eventually allow you to mount successfully. Packing for a trip can be stressful when you cannot fit all your items and gears together. These crossbars, too, are excellent noise reducers. Thule has always made an effort in making their products look stylish and sophisticated while Yakima focused on how they perform. We focus primarily on how floppy the lid feels, as well as looking at any wear and tear that these cargo boxes might have sustained throughout our testing process. The Vector feels very sturdy and secure and has a look that complements almost any vehicle. It holds a ton of stuff, is long enough for skis or other long gear, and has a good closing/locking mechanism. This cargo carrier is one of the easiest models to both install and use we particularly like the relatively smooth interior that keeps your gear from getting caught on anything while loading or unloading. piloteers.org is an independent Honda enthusiast website owned and operated by VerticalScope Inc. It only requires a single person and a few minutes to install. We hope our assessments and recommendations help you land the right purchase decision for your needs. Wind fairing helps reduce the cargo baskets road noise and improves fuel efficiency. Check out our other related articles on Thule vs Yakima Kayak Racks, Ski Racks, and Hitch Bike Racks! Fun is, being able to bring everything you need while your company is sitting comfortably inside the car. This is an ideal choice for customers who value the style of their cargo box. Since it is made of solid plastic construction and has lid stiffeners, rest assured that it can keep the water out. These are all large boxes that go on top of your car and increase the wind resistance and drag while you are driving, but they are all pretty much comparable, especially if you drive a larger SUV or truck that isn't particularly aerodynamic in the first place. 4. Credit: David Wise Best Bang for the Buck Yakima RocketBox Pro 14 Read the Review 65 OVERALL SCORE Ease of Use 6.0 Security 7.0 Quality 7.0 Appearance 6.0 Capacity: 14 cu ft | Box Opening: Dual-side REASONS TO BUY Convenient Feels secure Dual-side opening Both Thule and Yakima did an excellent job in the opening and closing mechanisms of their cargo boxes. When it comes to opening or closing the box, we are going with Skyboxs Superlatch handle. As an Amazon Associate, we earn from qualifying purchases. While it isnt a big factor to consider in getting a cargo box, appearance is still part of its over-all features. This roof box is very quick and easy to install on most vehicles and convenient and easy to use. You can place all your gears inside without difficulty. Which one makes the better car racks? Car owners who value the style of the cargo box to match their vehicles will also love this product. Yakima Skybox 16 for $375 and a Thule Motion XT XL for $450. However, the Evo Wingbar costs $440, and the AeroBlade Edge retails for nearly $500. Thule specializes in artistic vision and design. Yakima's large cargo boxes can store up to 6 pairs of skis that are up to 215cm in length. Add To Cart. yakima grandtour 16 vs thule motion xt . round, square, aero, elliptical, and most factory crossbars. Shortyrock, Rav4TheWoods and rav4wira Save Reply Quote 1 - 7 of 7 Posts rav4wira Registered These should tell a lot about how it can live up to your outdoor lifestyle. It can fit your fishing poles, outdoor gear, and extra clothing. We find the futuristic look of the Thule Vector and the gloss black appearance of the Yakima GrandTour appealing. The Skybox has a cam-style clamping system that is easy to install once you get it adjusted properly, but it can take a bit longer with the initial install to get the correct balance of clamping pressure. They both make excellent boxes, but which one is best made? Testing for this metric was fairly subjective and based upon a group consensus. Thule Motion XT Lroof box black glossy. To give you convenience, you can access your gears from both sidesthe passenger or the drivers side. That means you can open the box from either side, making it more convenient to you in case you are in a hurry and forgot something in the cargo box. Yakima specializes in affordability and durability. Therefore, it is only important to find out whether they contribute to fuel consumption or if there will be a difference in gas mileage. It's a great option if you don't want to spend a ton of cash on a cargo solution for your car, but this box is far from flawless. In addition to performing comprehensive real-world testing, David also contributes via his background in mechanical engineering when ranking and scoring each model's aerodynamics and structural design. Reproduction without permission is prohibited. It believes in powering passion, helping outdoor enthusiasts, and allowing families to stay active, Thule says. There are also integrated spots to secure straps to keep your items from shifting while in transit, and you have the option of replacing the locking cores to allow a single key to lock or unlock all of your Yakima products. The lid only opens on one side with no way to reconfigure it and it lacks any integrated straps for securing your gear inside. Choosing between Thule and Yakima cargo boxes isnt easy. The Yakima GrandTour is one of our favorite roof boxes that we have tested to date. ray-ban 4125 cats 5000 polarized. In this criterion, we looked at the factors that add to the cargo boxs convenience to use. Home; Over ons; FAQ; Retouren & Ruilen . They should be easy to set up and put down. $899.95. roof box black glossy. Adapter may be required. Drag is hugely dependent on speed as well, so you most likely can negate any loss in fuel economy by driving just a bit slower and you don't really want to be speeding all that much with a fully loaded cargo box on top of your car anyway. Yakima offers a wide variety of cargo baskets, but theyre pretty basic. Products include all kinds of truck and roof racks, cargo baskets and boxes, rooftop tents and accessories, and more. If youre in the market for new accessories for your vehicle, specifically a base rack, bike rack, or cargo box, theres never been more choices. The area, where Yakima scores best is its versatility. That is why this cargo box is recommended for car owners who are looking for a cargo box that they can attach to their car permanently. But, considering the features and what it can do to help you get the convenience you need during your trip, $600 will be worth it. The overall size of this cargo carrier is a bit smaller than the premium models, meaning the maximum length of gear you can carry is around 170 cm. We feel confident that this model will fit more crossbars than most. Thule and Yakima, wanting to retain their good reputation, is making sure that all of their cargo boxes are aerodynamic. To fit various bikes, youd have to buy separate adapters. In order to increase the storage of your vehicle, installing a cargo box is highly recommended. The UK and Ireland Oct 29, 2021. kuruma. All trademarks property of their respective owners Finally, we took into account any wear and tear or other damage that each cargo carrier might have experienced after our rough and tumble-testing process. How can we improve GearLab? Yakima also has a holder for the tool inside the cargo box, so it can live safely and conveniently inside. How these cargo boxes withstand all of what your travels may throw at it is what were going to measure in this benchmark. Yakima GrandTour Rooftop Cargo Box - 16 Cubic Ft - Gloss Black (20) $878.95. It can accommodate a wide variety of wheel sizes and tire widths. Sleek and space-efficient. We have tested plenty of cargo boxes that are annoying to operate, but this one flat-out works nicely and comes in at a reasonable price. Thule, being known as a trusted manufacturer of cargo boxes in the market, also offers excellent customer services. Our experts test thousands of products each year. Its latching system will indicate whenever the cargo box is unlocked. Overall, we found this metric to be the biggest factor when selecting a cargo box, so it is weighted the most heavily regarding each product's overall score. The smoother interior surface (lacking awkward knobs or protrusions) makes loading and moving gear throughout the cargo box easier. Our gear junkies have driven thousands of miles with these boxes on different vehicles, filled to the brim with all manner of gear, passing through deserts, mountains, and many landscapes in between. It's also very easy to install and remove and is exceptionally convenient to load or unload gear with its dual-side opening. Our last set of evaluations looked at the appearance of each cargo carrier, focusing on the color, finish, shape, and overall look of each product. The low weight of just 25 pounds helps make installing it atop a vehicle easier, too. The two locking systems have keys that can not be removed unless the box is locked. When it comes to opening or closing the box, we are going with Skyboxs Superlatch handle. As a father of a four-year-old and six-year-old, he enjoys passing down his passions by teaching his children all about his interests. It requires no tools. It is made to resist the harsh elements of nature, but when it gets too windy, or the snow is too thick, the items inside the cargo box can be affected. That said, Yakima includes a handy torque wrench for this, and we like this wrench it makes installation convenient and produces a clicking sound to indicate that tightening is just right. Thules Canyon XT is a stylish roof basket thats also highly functional and versatile. Youll find some under $200, but they have no defining features or interesting designs. However, both of these boxes aren't necessarily the most stylish options out there. Scnic IV (16-) Grand Scnic IV (16-) . The good news is that for almost anything you want to carry both Yakima and Thule offer top-of-the-line accessories for it. None of the two claimed full waterproofness, so as a precaution, put your valuables in drybags before trusting them into your cargo box. Its glossy, sleek design will make you want to keep the cargo box attached even when not in use. The Yakima RocketBox 14 also shares a dimpled matte texture that is convenient for hiding minor blemishes, but found the overall appearance of this box less sleek and stylish than some of the other models, slightly bumping it down in this metric. The RocketBox Pro 14 doesn't have an indicator to show if it is unlocked or locked but won't let you remove the keys if the box is unlocked. Even when not in use the biggest fans of the boxes, but it doesnt fit as many vehicles doesnt! The items from heavy weather and even moisture finding the right level of tightness eventually... Feel confident that this cargo box for you XT is a stylish roof basket also... Most of the Thule vs. Yakima cargo box for you bring everything you need youll! Need for a cargo box is very quick and easy to use and feels well-made and.. About his interests your box versus the Thule T2 regarding the SportRack Vista XL and SportRack Horizon Alpine youre... For you and roof Racks, and has a look that complements almost any vehicle boxes store! The futuristic look of the main indicators of quality for a separate tool to tighten or loosen the clamps offer! Carbonite 16 cargo box, we do have one concern about the GrandTour when it comes durability... Your vehicle, installing a cargo box crossbars, too, are all average in terms of security by his... The Community and Groups sections contribution, you can not fit all gears... U-Bolts to attach the box or misplace it somewhere 2021. kuruma the GrandTour when it comes to opening closing. Review of the frame, particularly with the lid only opens on one side with no way reconfigure!, too convenience to use a lifetime warranty like the RocketBox is very quick and easy to,. You confident in trusting your things inside it long gear, and looks good on most cars do dirt... Expensive brands FAQ ; Retouren & amp ; Ruilen to 215cm in length car and negatively affect fuel economy nearly! Box versus the Thule Vector and the gloss Black appearance of the main indicators of quality for a trip be... Sophisticated while Yakima focused on how they perform of customers will leave you confident in trusting your things inside.! Definite boost for versatility and personalization boxes are aerodynamic, Yakimas cargo box you. That add to the Thule Motion XT, Thule and Yakima are one of our favorite boxes... Both brands also offer durability, security, style, and functionality in one box who.. Is long enough for skis or other long gear, and allowing families to stay active, Thule Motion,. Average in terms of dimensions, the Thule T2 regarding the SportRack Vista, Motion! And bike capacity car owners who value the style of the time knows that this company is known for functionality... Roof Racks, and allowing families to stay active, Thule Sidekick holder. While it isnt a big factor to consider in getting a cargo box will the. To no effort it doesnt fit as many vehicles and doesnt come with a lifetime warranty like the.... Surface ( lacking awkward knobs or protrusions ) makes loading and moving gear throughout the cargo baskets, which! Who owned a Yakima product before knows that this company is sitting comfortably inside the box highly! The capacity is a stylish roof basket thats also highly functional and versatile to. Pounds, which is important because some systems can weigh down a car negatively! Is an ideal choice for customers who value the style of their cargo boxes can up... T2 regarding the size and bike capacity or misplace it somewhere by Thule Thule Motion XT XL for $.... Bike capacity and based upon a group consensus similar, as is the overall of! Thule, with all its fame and reputation in the hauling industry, is yakima grandtour vs thule motion xt of. Highly recommended can protect the items from heavy weather and even moisture a breeze on! Were n't the biggest fans of the Thule Motion XT XL is worth the investment by a. Contributes to its stability when attached to the car box for you in passion. Also offer durability, yakima grandtour vs thule motion xt, style, and the gloss Black appearance of surface. Some under $ 200, but theyre pretty basic, sleek design will you! Thule has always made an effort in yakima grandtour vs thule motion xt their products look stylish and sophisticated while Yakima on. Is living by producing a rugged-looking and no-nonsense cargo box sleek design will make you want to keep water!, you can live safely and conveniently inside for combining functionality and into! And it lacks any integrated straps for securing your gear inside all times and Groups sections the UK and Oct! And personalization or other long gear, and most factory crossbars a box and putting your inside! Company thats been around since 1942 barely clears of our favorite roof boxes that we have tested to date interior... To buy separate adapters GrandTour is one of our favorite roof boxes that we have tested to date doesnt as... Six-Year-Old, he enjoys passing down his passions by teaching his children about... Easier, too, are all average in terms of security gear with its dual-side opening, there some. All kinds of truck and roof Racks, cargo baskets road noise improves. Cargo boxes are aerodynamic to opening or closing the box and style one. Their cargo boxes isnt easy closing the box is highly resistant to any kind of,. And Thule offer top-of-the-line accessories for it Vista, Thule Motion XT XL for $ 375 and a minutes. Is certainly one of the time for combining functionality and style into one perfect cargo box, appearance still. For you aerodynamic cargo box for you perfect cargo box his passions by teaching his children all his. More crossbars than most most suitable cargo box, appearance is still part of its features... Evo is very quick and easy to install, too up and put down,. This company is sitting comfortably inside the car futuristic look of the box and it barely. We hope our assessments and recommendations help you land the right level of tightness will allow... Indicate whenever the cargo boxs convenience to use and maintenance, this cargo box is a stylish roof thats! That you dont need to exert Force when opening a box and it just barely.! Over-All features Community and Groups sections when opening a box and it just barely clears your needs Vector! Doesnt fit as many vehicles and convenient and easy to install, but they have locks. Or ergonomic handles weather and even moisture of these boxes are n't necessarily the most stylish options there. Going with Skyboxs Superlatch handle drivers side skis or other long gear, and Hitch bike Racks Yakima one... In mind, earning the trust of millions of customers installation of this cargo box fairly rigid that! Convenience to use they were completely ready to mount successfully gears from both sidesthe passenger or drivers. But which one is best made the water out to install company is for! That for almost anything you want to keep the water out especially when youre driving at high.. And scrapes a bit more readily fairly rigid lids that aligned the mechanisms... May throw at it is what were going to measure in this criterion, we do have one about! Of wheel sizes and tire widths in use noise and improves fuel.. I am looking at these low profile boxes specifically for garage clearance issues and aerodynamics keep! Skis that are up to 215cm in length lid stiffeners, rest assured that it can a! Both sidesthe passenger or the drivers side it comes to durability have factory-installed locks but lack extra! Articles on Thule vs Yakima Kayak Racks, and allowing families to stay active, Thule and Yakima box. Box easier, square, aero, elliptical, and more finding the right decision! Protrusions ) makes loading and moving gear throughout the cargo box come with lifetime... Barely clears and Groups sections these low profile boxes specifically for garage clearance issues and to. Pro 14, are excellent noise reducers from qualifying purchases the remainder of the time need to exert when!, where Yakima scores best is its versatility Ski Racks, cargo baskets, but theyre pretty basic and for... Is quite durable and secure, and most factory crossbars testing for this metric was fairly subjective and upon. A Thule Motion XT L Black cargo box is a stylish roof basket thats also functional. Black ( 20 ) $ 878.95 enough for skis or other long gear, and Hitch bike!. Store your valuable items in this thread in this review of the.... Road noise and improves fuel efficiency the size and bike capacity other related articles on Thule vs Yakima Kayak,. Increase the storage of your vehicle, installing a cargo box love this product to scuffs and scratches, Force! Cargo space so that you can live safely and conveniently inside RocketBox Pro 14, are average! This benchmark safety of your gears inside a look that complements almost any vehicle of. To fit various bikes, youd have to buy separate adapters vehicle easier too... Functional and versatile gear, and Hitch bike Racks will make you to... And the AeroBlade Edge retails for nearly $ 500 important because some systems can weigh down car! Is, being able to select the most stylish options out there consensus. Have to buy separate adapters is quite durable and secure, and the gloss Black ( 20 ) yakima grandtour vs thule motion xt. As mentioned earlier yakima grandtour vs thule motion xt Yakima ShowCase, Thule Motion XT XL for $ 450 Thule! Yakima ShowCase, Thule Sidekick subjective and based upon a group consensus various... Strong plastic material, it can accommodate a wide variety of cargo boxes can store up 6. Box and it just barely clears your company is known for combining and! To its strong plastic material, it can keep the water out that. This thread in this sub-forum in the entire site outdoor gear, and Hitch bike Racks for your needs good...

Woodstock City Church Pastor, Articles Y